Logistics of Choosing an Instrument

If you’re trying to decide which string instrument to play, it may be helpful for you to consider the logistics of each option. Of course, your decision should ultimately be based on which instrument resonates with you the most, but if you’re torn between a few options, this pro and con list for each orchestral string instrument might help you decide!

Violin

Pro:

• They are the smallest orchestral string instruments and the easiest to transport and carry.

• There is a lot of repertoire for the violin.

• The violin is lighter and easier to hold.

• It is the least expensive at the student level.

• Often, violins play the melody in orchestral music.

Con: 

• It is most competitive because it is a popular choice.

• This makes it harder to get spots in orchestras and/or scholarships.

• Some people find the high register irritating.

 

Viola 

Pro:

• Violists are sought after in orchestra and are more likely to receive scholarships.

• Competing for opportunities as a violist is less competitive.

• The viola is fairly easy to transport and carry.

• The rich tone is most similar to the human voice of any string instrument.

Con: 

• Violas are heavier and more likely to cause back pain than violins.

• Viola parts in orchestral music are often less involved.

• Not much solo repertoire has been written for the viola.

Cello

Pro:

• There is a lot of solo repertoire for the cello.

• Many find that the posture required to play cello is less awkward than that of the violin or viola.

Con:

• Celli are large and hard to carry and transport.

• When flying, you may need to purchase an extra seat.

• The cello can be more difficult to play because of its large size.

• The instrument is more difficult to tune when starting out.

• You can’t play standing up and you need a rock stop or strap to keep the endpin from slipping.

Double Bass

Pro:

• Finding opportunities as a bassist is less competitive.

• Bassists often play jazz, classical music, and more.

• The bass is often regarded as one of the most important instruments in the orchestra.

Con:

• It is difficult to carry and travel with because of its size and weight.

• You may need to invest in a hardshell case so you can “check-in” your bass on a plane or rent a bass at your destination.

• Finding music for chamber ensembles, solos, and duets is generally harder.

• Playing bass is very physically demanding.

• It can be difficult to find strings that are a good fit for you.

If you’re still having trouble deciding, you can try out instruments anytime at the K.C. Strings shop! Experimenting with holding and playing each instrument will likely be the most helpful in making your decision.